CPP contribution hikes penalize workers, dampen the economy

When the government makes employment more expensive, the sure result is fewer jobs

By Matthew Lau

The federal government began 2019 by taking a bigger bite out of workers’ paycheques: the combined employer and employee Canada Pension Plan payroll tax rose from 9.9 per cent of earnings to 10.2 per cent.

It’s the first of five annual payroll tax hikes. By the time the CPP tax hike is fully phased in, a worker earning $60,000 will pay $380 more in taxes each year and their employers will pay $380 more.

In addition to paying their portion of the tax, workers will bear part of the cost of the employer portion of the tax hike in the form of lower wages. That’s because when the government raises the cost of employing people, it’s not as profitable for businesses to hire as many workers unless they can reduce wages or slow the rate of future wage increases.

And when the government makes employment more expensive – to both the employer and the employee – the sure result is that there will be fewer jobs. This is particularly bad news for Atlantic Canada, since the region has persistently the highest unemployment rates and the weakest labour markets in the country, to go along with the heaviest overall tax burdens.

The federal payroll tax hike only makes things worse and is exacerbated by other hikes – including carbon and fuel tax increases, and income tax hikes in the form of bracket creep in Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island, where brackets aren’t indexed to consumer price inflation.

Those who support CPP expansion claim that it helps workers save for retirement. This is false. CPP is not a retirement savings account, and a worker who pays into CPP is not saving for his or her retirement. CPP is simply a transfer of income from workers to people who are retired.

Even supposing – incorrectly – that people saved for their own retirement through CPP, would expanding the program then be justified?

Certainly not, because even then CPP wouldn’t help workers who want to save more. Instead, it impedes these workers by reducing the disposable income they can save through investment decisions that – unlike CPP payments, which are mandatory – they make voluntarily.

Nor should it be any business of the federal government how much workers decide to save. As economist Milton Friedman put it in a 1999 interview: “Why is it that it is appropriate for government to tell me what fraction of my income I should save for my old age? If that’s okay, why can’t it come in and tell me exactly what fraction of my income I have to spend for food, what fraction for housing, what fraction for clothing?”

There are many good reasons why workers might want to save less for retirement than what the government dictates they set aside.

For example, if a worker has a disease that will prevent him from reaching old age and wants to earn as much income as possible today to leave to his family, it doesn’t make sense for the government to tax away his income and tell him that it’s helping him save for retirement.

I’s folly to imagine that federal politicians have greater knowledge of workers’ preferences on how their savings should be invested than workers themselves.

The CPP tax hike, far from enriching Canadians by helping them save more, only shrinks workers’ incomes and makes them worse off.

Matthew Lau is a writer with the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies.

© Troy Media

Just Posted

Gas prices spike in northern B.C. ahead of the long weekend

Fuel went up 17 cents overnight in Prince Rupert

Rocking Through The Ages with grads of 2019

Barriere Secondary’s Class of 2019 presented their show ‘Rocking Through The Ages’… Continue reading

Explore the true meaning of Easter

Bunnies and baskets, chocolates and candies. It’s that time of year when… Continue reading

Workshop coming on how to apply for funding and attract volunteers for your non-profit

One of the biggest challenges to community not-for-profits is the ability to… Continue reading

Did you know our planet is constantly under attack?

The planet is comprised of a remarkable set of organisms that, when… Continue reading

It was no Kentucky Derby: B.C. girls host foot-long snail race

Two Grade 3 students in White Rock put four snails to the test in a hotly-contested street race

Police probe eight fires set at B.C. elementary school

Nanaimo RCMP say fires appear to have been set intentionally

Undercover cops don’t need warrant to email, text suspected child lurers: court

High court decision came Thursday in the case of Sean Patrick Mills of Newfoundland

Whitecaps fans stage walkout over club’s response to allegations against B.C. coach

Soccer coach has been suspended by Coastal FC since February

Three climbers presumed dead after avalanche in Banff National Park

One of the men is American and the other two are from Europe, according to officials

VIDEO: Trump tried to seize control of Mueller probe, report says

Special counsel Robert Mueller’s report revealed to a waiting nation Thursday

BC Ferries to pilot selling beer and wine on select sailings

Drinks from select B.C. breweries and VQA wineries will be available on the Swartz Bay to Tsawwassen route

B.C. awaits Kenney’s ‘turn off taps,’ threat; Quebec rejects Alberta pipelines

B.C. Premier John Horgan said he spoke with Kenney Wednesday and the tone was cordial

Most Read