We can’t have our cake and eat it too

Editor, The Times:

My father, Ralph Ritcey, has asked me to respond to the editorial you recently ran in your paper concerning the issue surrounding the decline of caribou in our province. Some of the original research into the needs of the caribou was carried out in Wells Gray Provincial Park during his time there and father has been a proponent for the caribou ever since.

His analysis is as follows:

The focus on predators as the critical part of the decline in caribou numbers ignores the fact that with, or without, predators – caribou still need to eat to survive. The bottom line is that caribou need the arboreal lichens found in old-growth stands of timber.

This preoccupation with depredation is evidenced in Fletcher’s erroneous assertion that “Newfoundland’s herds are many times bigger than B.C.’s total population, and decline there as well as here is attributed to climate shifts, resurgence of wolves and grizzly bears and their access to prey via roads and snowmobile tracks.” As Newfoundland has neither wolves nor grizzly bears I wonder where Fletcher is getting his facts.

Fletcher again oversimplifies the situation when he points out that the caribou numbers are declining in Wells Gray Park “with no industrial activity.” Caribou are highly mobile animals and require vast tracts of land to survive. Because the lichens they feed on are slow-growing, they need to be able to feed in an area and then leave it for an extended period while the lichens grow back. The logging outside of Wells Gray Park is what is having a direct impact on the Wells Gray caribou.

The science is clear on the subject – if you want to have sustainable numbers of caribou you have to give up some of the economic benefits that are associated with our logging industry.

We can’t “have our cake and eat it too!”

Frank Ritcey,

Kamloops, B.C.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Clearwater mayor unimpressed with Forest Minister’s inaction on local tenure transfer

Mayor Merlin Blackwell says he’s ready to lead delegation to Victoria

Valley Voice: Remembering the tools of yesteryear

Barriere and District Heritage Society talks about a few mundane modern tasks that were once laborous and time consuming

Replacement of Beaton Road Bridge in Kamloops set to begin

Construction will begin March 2, closing the east end of the road to all traffic

Blue River Powder Packers blocked from accessing popular riding areas

Snowmobile tourism group loses revenue over lack of notice from logging activity

New group gives support to children with exceptionalities

Clearwater YCS is offering new support program for families with children who have exceptionalities

VIDEO: 2020 BC Winter Games wrap up in Fort St. John as torch passes to Maple Ridge

More than 1,000 athletes competed in the 2020 BC Winter Games

Harvey Weinstein found guilty of sex crimes in landmark #MeToo trial

The cases against the Hollywood mogul started the #MeToo movement

CRA puts focus on paper returns as tax-filing season opens

The federal tax collector expects to handle about two million paper returns this calendar year out of roughly 26 million filings

StatCan says 3.2 million living in poverty, including 566,000 children

The child poverty rate of 8.2 per cent however is little changed from 2017

Teck withdraws application for Frontier mine, citing discourse over climate change

The Vancouver-based company said it will take a $1.13-billion writedown on the Frontier project in Alberta

B.C. VIEWS: Pipeline dispute highlights need for clarity

As the B.C. treaty process grinds on, uncertainty remains

‘A long way to go’: UNBC hosts Moose Hide Campaign gathering on Feb. 24

The event is a part of a movement to stand up against violence inflicted on women and children

Still six cases of COVID-19 in B.C. despite reports of Air Canada passenger: ministry

Health ministry wouldn’t comment on specific flight routes

Most Read